
The Biggest College Football Upsets of the 21st Century
Go deeper into the upsets that everyone missed beforehand and spot dangerous underdogs with massive value
Beyond the Lines · Oct 28, 2026 · 5 min readThe best college football upsets can seriously mess with NCAAF odds and wreck a parlay, especially when the heavy favorite was supposed to be your anchor leg.
They don’t happen every NCAA season, but college football upsets have a bit of a formula that you can spot. Look for a huge spread, a live QB, maybe a coach that can make a difference and an overlooked program that has had the game circled since the summer.
Appalachian State vs. Michigan, 2007
Appalachian State’s 34-32 win at No. 5 Michigan is the quickest answer if you ask college football watchers and NCAAF betting fans what’s the biggest upset they’ve seen in the 2000s.
App State’s Corey Lynch blocked a field goal that clinched the insane ending. The Mountaineers had already set the table all afternoon though. Winning the game was no accident. They led 28-17 at halftime. The crowd helped make it a bigger moment than it already was: close to 110,000 Wolverines fans cranking up the energy in the stadium to 11.
What did people miss? What did bettors miss? That would have been a sweet payday and you know at least a handful of people scored a season-changing payday. The spread was a crazy -33 for Michigan at some books (or maybe not that crazy: we still see some 4-5 TD spreads every season in NCAA football).
Here are a few of the overlooked factors that might help your college football betting strategy as you try to spot the next App State.
First, the Mountaineers were an FCS (Football Championship Subdivision) program, but they were also the two-time defending FCS national champions. The differences between FBS teams and FCS ones can be massive on paper. FBS teams have bigger rosters, huge budgets for coaching, recruiting, and amenities, and could offer 85 scholarships compared to 63 for FCS teams.
The games they play against each other are “money” games for the FCS team, who gets a huge check to travel to the FBS school, a check that helps fund the smaller school’s program for the season. For the FBS teams, the term is a little less kind. They’re called “body bag” games, basically giant mismatches that allow them to get reps and a breather in the schedule against typically much weaker teams.
Second, Jerry Moore’s champion Mountaineers team brought an established spread-option offense and a top quarterback, Armanti Edwards, to the field. Michigan, meanwhile, was replacing seven defensive starters. Both red flags if you’re taking a 33-point favorite against a supposed cupcake.
Edwards threw three touchdown passes and ran for another. The Mountaineers spread Michigan out all day, capitalizing on the holes with Michigan’s backups on D. No one was counting scholarship differences when App State was dominating individual matchups.
Michigan fell completely out of the AP Top 25 with that loss. The win even prompted the AP to let voters include FCS teams in its Top 25 poll, which had been reserved for FBS programs only before that epic win at Ann Arbor.

Stanford vs. USC, 2007
Five weeks after that App State-Michigan shocker, Stanford delivered an even bigger shock against the betting spread.
The Cardinal were 41-point underdogs heading down the highway to play No. 2 USC. USC was on a 35-game home winning streak. Stanford just lost the week before 41-3 to ASU.
They won 24-23 behind quarterback Tavita Pritchard, who was making his first college start. His previous playing time amounted to three pass attempts. We won’t fault you or any other bettors who didn’t have Stanford on the moneyline that weekend. The spread though, at basically 6 touchdowns, should always raise some question marks.
The stat sheet wouldn’t have suggested the spread was too far off. USC outgained Stanford 459-235. But the Cardinal nailed the turnover differential, creating five of them by the Trojans. The Cardinal also blocked an extra point that ended up being the difference in the final score. John David Booty, playing elite QB for USC, also cracked a finger on his throwing hand during the second quarter, which complicated an already messy USC performance.
For first-year Stanford coach Jim Harbaugh, this was an early statement game too.
It took some luck for sure, but Harbaugh wasn’t new to winning. He had gone 29-6 at San Diego, including back-to-back 11-1 seasons. Sometimes the coaching is enough to keep a team believing in themselves, backed up by a smart game plan.
For football bettors, we need to be honest here. There’s no keen insight that would have had you sniffing out a potential win by Stanford. What this game does show you though: 41-point spreads should be checked extra carefully if you are leaning towards the favorite. Anything can happen in college football.

Howard vs. UNLV, 2017
The spread gets even bigger for this one. Howard’s 43-40 victory at UNLV meant a 45-point underdog got it done. They won outright and made it (still today) the biggest point-spread upset in college football history.
Caylin Newton, Cam’s younger brother, generated 330 yards of total offense. He rushed for 190 yards and two touchdowns while adding 140 passing yards and another score.
The missed danger for the Rebs and for anyone who didn’t spot Howard as a live ‘dog was all in the QB. Newton was a dual-threat, the type of college QB that can mess with favored defenses all day. He gave Howard an attacking dimension that they couldn’t answer, and it helped that he was a first-year player with nothing to lose. UNLV probably didn’t have a lot of film on him and probably got cocky.
Like the App State-Wolverines game a decade earlier, an unfamiliar FCS opponent was probably taken as an automatic mismatch.
You can spot these live underdogs occasionally and make a case for them with the right ingredients: a solid, two-threat QB, a smart coach, or a team with a recent championship pedigree and mentality. You still won’t see them listed in the National Championship Futures, but you will be able to hit some serious numbers on the odds board for that one weekend.