College Football's Most Ridiculous Upsets

Some games in NCAA Football defy all logic

Beyond the Lines · Nov 3, 2026 · 4 min read

The best college football upsets make you check the score twice.

The App State-Michigan upset is the one every college football betting fan points to whenever they think about taking a huge underdog for a few bucks.

There are other games, more ridiculous ones, over the history of the NCAA that stand out though. Most had spreads of 35+ points. Huge red flags for the underdog in the weeks leading up to it. Injuries to key players.

Still, sometimes a ‘dog just has it in them for three hours on a random Saturday.

Every weekend, NCAAF odds offer a few tantalizing spreads and moneylines that feel like the favorite is a lock. You want to make sure every season that you sprinkle in some long shots though, and this list tells you why. These underdogs won’t be the ones we’re suggesting for your NCAA Futures bets, but they can make for a nice weekend payday.

Georgia Southern 26, Florida 20: They Passed on Passing

Georgia Southern beat Florida in the Swamp in 2013 without completing a pass. Not one. The Eagles attempted only three and they all went incomplete. The Eagles still won 26-20.

They did it by rushing for 429 yards. Georgia Southern averaged 7.9 yards per rushing attempt, so that makes the lack of passing easier to understand. As you might hear in the Georgia area: If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.

This was, we should note, not a great Florida team. It wasn’t the Urban Meyer or Steve Spurrier era. Will Muschamp was the head coach, and his name is about as memorable as the starting Gators QB, Skyler Mornhinweg. He was the 3rd-string quarterback forced into action because the first and second stringers were hurt.

The loss dropped the Gators to 4-7 and extended their losing streak to six games. Pretending Georgia Southern had beaten a championship contender would weaken the story rather than improve it.

Still, we’ll call it a ridiculous upset when it’s a win by an FCS team as a 27.5-point underdog, in The Swamp, without completing a single pass.

A Stanford running back in a white No. 33 jersey breaks away from UCLA defenders.

Oregon State 21, Washington 20: Beavers Chip Away

There are bad vibes heading into a college football game, and then there’s Oregon State’s mojo heading into Washington in October 1985. One local columnist called the Beavers “an embarrassment to the Pac-10 Conference”.

The Beavers, to be fair, have almost always been the weaker sibling to the Oregon Ducks. Expectations for this matchup were not high. They were 38-point underdogs for the game against the Huskies.

Oregon State had lost their previous two games against USC and Washington State by a combined 97-0. Their starting quarterback, Erik Wilhelm, was injured. That left true freshman Rich Gonzales taking over an offense that had just spent consecutive Saturdays failing to score a point. It would have taken a complete homer to bet on a Beavers win. There probably wasn’t even a moneyline for the Beavers to win the game: the books wouldn’t have wanted to touch it.

Washington, meanwhile, was playing at home against a conference opponent it had beaten for 10 consecutive years.

Instead, Oregon State led 14-10 at halftime. Washington recovered to take a 20-14 advantage, but the Beavers stayed close enough for one special-teams play to change everything.

Late in the fourth quarter, Andre Todd blocked a Washington punt. Lavance Northington recovered it in the end zone, and the extra point gave Oregon State a 21-20 lead that stayed as the final score.

Oregon State weren’t really rescued from a blowout by just a fluky blocked punt, although that helped. They’d played the Huskies close all afternoon and put themselves within one play of winning. Plus, that blocked punt was based on a designed play, taken from game film prep earlier in the week by the Beavers’ coaching staff.

They also managed to use the bad press as motivation. “We sort of used that stuff in a quiet way,” said coach Dave Kragthorpe. “The papers were there and being passed around that morning as guys were getting taped. They were certainly all aware of it, no question.”

An Appalachian State player in a white No. 28 jersey celebrates in a packed stadium.

Temple 28, Virginia Tech 24: Winless Teams Have to Win Sometimes

If you thought a team that just got smoked 97-0 over two games had no business winning, then the Temple Owls’ performance on October 17, 1998 was equally crazy.

The Owls were 0-6. Virginia Tech was undefeated and ranked No. 14 in the AP Top 25 poll. Temple was a 35.5-point underdog. This was supposed to be a homecoming celebration in Blacksburg, not a test of any kind.

To add to the lopsided matchup (on paper), Temple also entered the game with a 0-26 record in Big East road games. It doesn’t stop there. Injuries meant 10 Owls were making their first starts of the season. Freshman quarterback Devin Scott was making his first career start against a defense ranked fourth nationally. Literally nothing should have caused NCAAF bettors to think the Owls would get within five TDs, much less win outright.

For a while, everything did follow the expected script. Virginia Tech moved ahead 17-0. The homecoming party was well underway.

Cue the needle scratch.

Temple instead scored 28 of the game’s final 35 points. Scott threw for 155 yards and two touchdowns, then supplied the winning score himself on a one-yard run. The Owls left with a 28-24 victory. This game was a virtual one-off. They won only one more game that season.

Virginia Tech still outgained the Owls 480-357, but Temple caused two INTs and a fumble and made the most of their opportunities.