The Biggest NFL Upsets That Nobody Saw Coming

Spotting strengths in underdogs can pay off, especially when huge spreads are in play

Beyond the Lines · Oct 24, 2026 · 4 min read

The biggest NFL upsets usually get the same treatment after they happen. The clichés come out and NFL betting types use them to console themselves if they missed it or took a bad beat. “The favorite overlooked their opponent”, “it was one lucky play”, etc.

The more useful thing to do is question before kickoff whether the underdog had a plausible way to win. Could they disrupt the quarterback and make him uncomfortable all game? Can they attack a weakness that the favorite’s strong record had covered up so far? Is there a game script that makes sense that gives the ‘dog a real shot?

Bottom line: Look past the hype, and that includes the NFL odds. Judging the better team and judging the matchup are not always the same exercise.

Jets Over Colts: The Distraction Play

Joe Namath’s guaranteed win became one of the lasting impressions of Super Bowl III.

Broadway Joe’s swagger wasn’t just hot air though. His New York Jets had some legitimate reasons to be confident.

The Jets entered the January 1969 NFL title matchup as 18-point underdogs against Baltimore. You barely see a team laying 18 points in the NFL anymore. San Francisco was -18.5 against the Chargers in Super Bowl XXIX.

The Jets smashed that Super Bowl spread and won outright 16-7.

New York’s game script surprised everyone. It was a deception move, although we’re still not sure if it was intentional. While Namath spent the lead-up to the game attracting a massive spotlight in his fur coats and endless talking, when the game started the Jets leaned on running back Matt Snell. He rushed for 121 yards on 30 carries and scored their only touchdown. Namath’s guarantee came through but he wasn’t really the one who made it happen. He didn’t throw any touchdown passes and barely got past 200 yards in the air.

The smart money looked past the loudmouth QB and might have spotted mismatches that would bring the game much closer than 3-4 scores. Snell was a force all season long. New York knew they could move Baltimore’s defense on the ground. That would eat up the clock too. At the same time, the Jets’ defense also intercepted four passes.

It was a blue-collar win. The Jets didn’t need Namath throwing for big plays. Their blocking, running game and defense gave them the smarter path.

The lesson for NFL bettors plays out a few times every season. Double-digit spreads, especially those going for 14+ points, need to be seriously analyzed before you bet the favorite. And if the media is going nuts over some player on the favorite, analyze it even closer. The actual matchup might reveal some edges when it comes to the underdog.

Christian McCaffrey of the San Francisco 49ers runs through a Philadelphia Eagles tackle.

Patriots Over Rams: The Better Offense Did Not Control the Terms

Before New England really started its two-decade Brady-Belichick run, they were on the other side of the bet.

The Pats were 14-point underdogs against St. Louis in Super Bowl XXXVI in February 2002. The Rams had the offensive reputation, racking up crazy numbers every game, including this one.

St. Louis outgained New England 427-267. If you saw that ahead of time, you’re doubling down on the favorites. Instead, the Patriots forced three turnovers, converted them into points multiple times, and committed none themselves. The score ended up 20-17 and the dynasty had begun.

That is the difference between predicting offensive production and predicting a football game. The Rams moved the ball. They simply did not turn enough of that movement into a winning scoreboard.

The warning signs were already there. We’re not sure how many NFL bettors saw them, but if they did and went with the Pats to cover or actually win outright, they would have had a Super Sunday themselves. St. Louis had committed 44 regular-season turnovers, among the most in the NFL. New England had forced three of them in their November meeting, two months ahead of the Super Bowl. The Rams could pile up yards without putting a game out of reach. Those turnovers would have been a red flag to just auto-betting the Rams, especially by 14 points.

The Patriots knew about this weakness and made disruption and smart defensive schemes more important than going toe-to-toe on offense, a battle they knew they couldn’t win.

Denver Broncos quarterback Bo Nix walks off the field through a crowd of cameras.

The Helmet Catch: Giants Over Patriots

The Patriots got a taste of their own medicine, and then some, a few years later in the 2008 Super Bowl.

New England entered Super Bowl XLII with an unbeaten season and a chance to finish a historic championship run. Only the 1972 Miami Dolphins went 100% unbeaten, and they did it with fewer games to play.

In the regular-season finale that same season, New York had pushed the Patriots before losing 38-35. The Giants even held a 12-point third-quarter lead in that game.

The more concrete warning against the -12 spread for New England was New York’s pass rush. The Giants led the NFL with 53 regular-season sacks. Like the Rams’ turnover numbers in the example above, this is a signal that can be used in betting, not just noise or a storyline.

That strength translated directly in the Super Bowl. New York sacked Tom Brady five times and registered nine quarterback hits. Sure, they needed a miracle catch by David Tyree on their way to a 17-14 upset win, but even without that they would almost definitely have covered.

The market gave too much weight to New England’s overall superiority and too little to the specific threat facing its offense. Another lesson to beware of double-digit spreads, especially in huge games.

The sharper approach is to identify the underdog’s winning script before kickoff. If that script needs miracles or huge performances from mid-tier QBs, the big price probably has a good explanation. If it looks like the underdog’s single strength can attack the favorite all game long, that could be the sign to fade the favorite.