
The Greatest Rivalries the NFL Accidentally Created
Real NFL rivalries developed by scheduling, competition, history and geography, not careful planning by the league
Rivalry Lounge · Nov 5, 2026 · 4 min readThe best NFL rivalries usually develop in a few different ways.
Two teams keep blocking each other’s path to a Super Bowl title or at least a later round in the NFL Playoffs. Being close together on the map and battling for decades also helps create bitterness. Maybe one play/player sets off something that goes beyond regular football. Or two A-listers battle for the title of being called the best.
All the ingredients of a rivalry get spread beyond the locker room to the fan base too, and they have nothing to do with actual football but everything to do with human emotions. Resentment, obsession, jealousy, pride, anger.
Sometimes the league will try to manufacture a rivalry through marketing, but the real rivalries tap into these emotions too and they can’t be created through a TV promo.
Bears vs. Packers
Chicago and Green Bay definitely didn’t need any marketing campaigns to create bitterness. Their rivalry comes through decades of clashes.
Their first meeting came in 1921, when the team then known as the Chicago Staleys beat the Packers 20-0. You know the rivalry is legitimate because 1921 predates the modern NFL and its multi-billion-dollar marketing and entertainment machine by over 40 years.
Old rivalries operate differently from newer ones. Fans literally inherit an opinion before they understand the game. You’re born in Place A, so you automatically hate teams from Place B. Beating the other team becomes part of what a successful season should look like, even when a league title isn’t part of the picture.
Geography helps make that feeling stick. Nearby fan bases have more opportunities to run into each other away from the stadium. “Familiarity breeds contempt,” the old saying goes. The result of the latest chapter of any NFL rivalry follows people into workplaces, family gatherings, local bars and keeps it going.
Familiarity also needs repetition and tradition, and this is where the “accidental” part of this story comes into play. The NFL’s division structure has teams playing their three divisional opponents at home and away each season. That’s two Bears vs. Packers games every year for decades. Throwing them together because they share roughly the same spot of American real estate and then having them despise each other for a century is just a happy accident.
The rivalry has seen NFL legends get a taste and play a huge role. Walter Payton, Dick Butkus, Mike Ditka for Da Bears, and Bart Starr, Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers for the Pack. It was Rodgers yelling at Bears’ fans back in 2021, that gave us a taste of what the rivalry means to players: “All my bleeping life, I own you. I still own you. I still own you!” Rodgers had a 25-5 record against Chicago in his career. Yeah, he kinda did own them.
For the record, the Packers currently lead the Bears 110-98-6 all-time, including regular-season and playoff games.

Cowboys vs. 49ers
Dallas and San Francisco make the opposite case of the Bears-Packers’ history or geography.
Turns out teams don’t need to share a division or a regional identity to create a top-tier rivalry.
The Cowboys and 49ers played three consecutive NFC Championship Games following the 1992, 1993, and 1994 seasons. Dallas won the first two and San Francisco won the third. Each winner went on to win the Super Bowl. Teams just need to have high stakes and some reps. Dwight Clark’s miracle called “The Catch” helped set the tone a decade earlier when the teams met for the NFC Championship.
And having some personalities involved helps.
Before the second of those championship meetings, Cowboys’ coach Jimmy Johnson publicly said, “We will win the ballgame.” Dallas then won 38-21. Terrell Owens on the Niners smashing the ball on the Cowboys’ midfield star and getting trucked by George Teague helped matters. Emmitt Smith returning the favor in the same game turned up the heat even more.
None of that was orchestrated by the league, and in fact they probably don’t love (or at least don’t publicly admit to it) players brawling on the field. It was and still is a matchup that football fans circle on the calendar every season.

Brady vs. Manning
Tom Brady versus Peyton Manning was a legitimate NFL rivalry. A personal feud, no.
When you saw the TV promos with the graphics of their next head-to-head battle, you would’ve thought they were actually bitter rivals.
The competitive stakes were real. Their teams met 17 times with both quarterbacks involved. Brady held an 11-6 overall advantage, but Manning’s teams won three of their four AFC Championship Game meetings. Super Bowl futures basically had to factor in the Manning effect when it came to the Patriots dynasty during his peak years.
Friendship was the main factor between them though, not some bitter, league-created rivalry.
At Brady’s number-retirement celebration, Manning discussed their private connection during their playing careers. The two quarterbacks competed fiercely without privately disliking each other. It helped that they didn’t actually play positions that caused them to smash into each other on the field, we’re guessing.
Some media types might try to pick up some crumbs of an interview quote to fan the flames, but in this case no one was buying it.
The closest issue came in 2015, when during the Deflategate investigation a private email from Brady was made public: “I've got another 7 or 8 years. He has 2. That's the final chapter. Game on.”
Manning got a text from Brady after that email leaked, apologizing for it, and he said he never minded it in the first place. It helped that Manning walked away from the game on top, winning Super Bowl 50 in February 2016.