The Greatest Cinderella Stories in College Basketball

Look back at the underdogs with unexpected tournament runs that became part of college basketball history.

Beyond the Lines · Nov 11, 2026 · 5 min read

March Madness is dominated by the biggest schools and the players who go on to big NBA careers.

Every so often, a little-known program becomes the center of the basketball conversation in March instead, and college basketball betting gets turned on its head.

NCAAB odds get a full reset when the top seeds start falling and fans start rearranging their schedules around the Cinderella team’s next game.

NC State, Loyola Marymount, Davidson and Florida Gulf Coast reached that point in different ways but they’re all great chapters in the history of the Madness.

NC State, 1983: Cinderella 101

We’ve all seen the mad dash by NC State’s Jim Valvano right after they shocked the hoops world back in the early days of March Madness. It’s always at the top of the list whenever any kind of Cinderella story comes to mind for college basketball.

Fans (most of the people reading this who weren’t born yet) wouldn’t have known that NC State was not an unknown school crashing college basketball’s party. It was an ACC program with a national championship already in its history.

What made the 1983 Wolfpack different was their #6 position that season. It’s not a crazy-low number like a #12 or #15, but the way they were winning games in the tournament started to give off those Cinderella vibes. They kept surviving games they could/should have lost.

Valvano’s team needed two overtimes to beat Pepperdine 69-67 in the NCAA tournament opener. A first round exit was that close. The Wolfpack then took their fans even closer to the edge, beating UNLV 71-70. As if the heart attacks needed more fuel, they scored a 63-62 victory over #1 in the West Region, Virginia, in the regional final. Before the championship game even arrived, NC State was pretty much wearing the glass slipper.

You can call those close games flukes. A bounce here or a missed or made free throw there and people would barely know who Valvano was. What those games did though was pressure-test the Wolfpack, making sure they could eventually repeatedly handle the pressure of a national championship game.

The final opponent was Houston, the No. 1 seed in the Midwest. The Cougars looked unstoppable. It was the Phi Slama Jama days, where almost every game during the NCAA basketball season had Houston making spectacular dunks. The names on the jerseys are still ones we know today: Drexler and Olajuwon became Hall-of-Fame NBA stars.

NC State didn’t have the cool nickname or the A-listers, although they did have some future NBA players. Still, they came into the game as 7-point underdogs. Before the tournament tipped off three weeks earlier, the Wolfpack had +2500 odds to win it all compared to Houston’s much shorter price.

Lorenzo Charles provided the final jam for a 54-52 victory, another highlight reel clip that is still shown today, right before Valvano went ham on the court.

A Florida Gulf Coast player throws down a dunk during the 2013 NCAA Tournament.

Loyola Marymount, 1990: Way Bigger Than Basketball

Loyola Marymount’s story goes beyond the usual Cinderella treatment.

They went through the toughest thing a team can imagine right before the tournament started. Marymount lost teammate Hank Gathers, who collapsed during a West Coast Conference tournament game and died on March 4, 1990.

The remaining conference tournament games were canceled. As regular-season WCC champions, the Lions owned the league’s automatic NCAA bid. Coach Paul Westhead left the decision about continuing to his players. They chose to play.

The Lions were seeded No. 11, a double-digit spot that sees most teams gone by the Sweet Sixteen at the latest. Loyola Marymount opened against New Mexico State. Bo Kimble scored 45 points in a 111-92 victory, an insane number for a college star. Kimble will be more remembered for what he did at the foul line. He made a left-handed free throw in tribute to Gathers, keeping a promise to honor his friend. With close to 50 points in the game, you have to wonder if Gathers was helping Kimble sink shots all game.

Then came this: Loyola Marymount 149, defending national champion Michigan 115. Kimble didn’t have 45 again but he didn’t need to. His teammate Jeff Fryer made 11 threes and scored 41 points.

Next up, #7 ’Bama. Sweet Sixteen. Didn’t matter. Alabama forced the Lions into a much slower game that was the complete opposite of Marymount’s run-and-gun style, but the emotional Cinderella got it done again. Marymount survived 62-60. The Lions reached the Elite Eight before losing to UNLV, 131-101.

An NC State player in a red No. 43 jersey dunks at the rim in front of a packed crowd.

Davidson, 2008: Intro to Steph Curry

Watching Davidson’s 2008 run now reminds you that their most famous alum, Steph Curry, wasn’t always a superstar. He was just a sophomore guard helping a No. 10 seed take on opponents with programs that sounded like actual schools, not like someone’s last name.

Against Gonzaga, Curry scored 40 points, including 30 after halftime. Davidson won 82-76. Curry and his teammates were only getting started.

Georgetown led Davidson by 17 early in the second half of their next game. The Wildcats came back to win 74-70, with Curry scoring 30 this time. Then they beat Wisconsin 73-56 in the Sweet 16 behind another 33 points from guess who?

The Elite Eight took another Cinderella victim. Against Kansas, Curry poured in 25 and nearly delivered the team to the Final Four. Kansas won 59-57 after Davidson’s final possession ended with a missed three-pointer (not by Curry).

Low seeds with a generational talent can make a deep run in the NCAA March Madness tournament. College basketball betting fans can try to spot them and score a solid underdog payout too.

Florida Gulf Coast, 2013: Dunk City

Thirty years exactly after Phi Slama Jama, Dunk City was born.

Florida Gulf Coast made their NCAA tournament debut that year as a No. 15 seed. No one knew them as Dunk City. They were barely on the map.

Their 78-68 opening victory over No. 2 Georgetown was surprising enough. In the history of March Madness, #15 seeds have gone 11-153 against #2 seeds. The Eagles followed that shocker with more jams in an 81-71 win over San Diego State two days later and made history. Florida Gulf Coast became the first No. 15 seed to reach the Sweet 16.

Their high-flying finishes made the Cinderella story even more popular. Chase Fieler was the Mayor of Dunk City and players like Sherwood Brown made the highlight reels regularly. Fans actively wanted to keep watching.

Florida ended the Eagles’ run in that Sweet 16 and few people remember the names from that team. Like the actual Cinderella, it’s almost like the whole thing was just a fairy tale.