The NFL's Greatest “Wait…They Actually Did It” Moments

Betting on NFL comebacks and upsets can produce big paydays, and spotting them early is a science

Beyond the Lines · Nov 1, 2026 · 4 min read

We covered some of the NFL’s biggest all-time upsets here. That includes Jets-Colts in the Super Bowl, plus the Patriots being on different sides of different upsets.

These next ones also cover how the ‘dogs actually did it, but it includes a comeback too. And if you mine them for enough clues, your next NFL bet slip or playoff futures play might include an underdog with a solid plus-money payout that very few people saw coming.

There are plenty of dramatic moments in the NFL archives, but some entire games told a full story from start to finish.

Jaguars vs. Broncos, 1996 Playoffs

The Jacksonville Jaguars arrived in Denver as a second-year franchise facing the AFC’s top seed. The Broncos had finished the regular season 13-3. The Jags entered the divisional playoff as a double-digit underdog. This looked like one of those parts in a young franchise where they go home with a “moral” victory and something to build on.

Denver jumped out to a 12-0 lead. For an untested road ‘dog, that could have meant a slight panic and a chance to unravel. Instead, Tom Coughlin’s Jags stayed in the game and kept their heads. QB Mark Brunell was no Elway, but he was a solid vet with some skills. Jacksonville scored on five consecutive possessions while holding Denver scoreless across that stretch. That translated into a 23-12 fourth-quarter advantage.

Running back Natrone Means was the real A-lister on the Jaguars’ sideline. He was central to that turnaround too.

Don’t forget weather in January when it comes to NFL playoff betting.

Cold weather and snow can level the playing field in a big way. In this case, there was no snow but the wind chill coming in from the Rockies brought the field temperature to 27 degrees. In a cold wind QBs can’t get a great feel for the ball and it can turn into stone for receivers.

That means the run game has to generate offense. Means’ 140 rushing yards on 21 carries gave Jacksonville a real shot. That double-digit spread was based on the teams’ regular season and their rosters. All it takes for an upset is 60 minutes where a few things can go sideways for the favorite.

NFL underdog bettors might also look for a dual-threat QB in tough conditions. Brunell produced a late 29-yard scramble that moved the Jaguars to the Broncos’ 21. He then found Jimmy Smith for a 16-yard touchdown with 3:39 remaining.

Jacksonville won 30-27.

Denver Broncos quarterback John Elway in a close-up under his helmet.

New England vs. Atlanta, Super Bowl 2017

New England’s comeback against Atlanta in Super Bowl LI belongs in any collection of NFL “wait…they actually did it” moments. It wasn’t an underdog upsetting a favorite though. It just defied every statistical probability.

The Patriots trailed 28-3 in the third quarter before winning 34-28 in overtime, completing the largest comeback in Super Bowl history. This almost doesn’t make sense. The Falcons’ win probability at 25 points up that late in the 3rd quarter was between 99.5 and 99.9%.

Tom Brady was part of it, sure. A big part. So we’re not advising betting fans to look for the next Brady to make a live betting play halfway through a title game.

James White finished with a Super Bowl-record 14 catches for 110 yards. He also scored three touchdowns and a two-point conversion. He was kind of robbed for the MVP title by brand-name Brady, but that’s for another discussion.

There were plenty of other heroes that changed this game that deserve mention but have gotten a little lost under Brady’s shadow. Dont’a Hightower causing a Matt Ryan fumble at 28-12. Danny Amendola scoring a key TD.

Atlanta’s decisions, and New England’s ability to punish them, mattered as much as the comeback’s key players.

The betting takeaways? When a team has the coaching and the horses, never count them out. People who got into the live betting action at halftime or into the third quarter would have gotten great odds for a Pats eventual win.

New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning drops back to pass in a blue No. 10 jersey.

Bills vs. Vikings, 2018: Josh Allen Didn’t Read the Assignment

Not every NFL upset needs a playoff stage to produce drama. Or a payday for underdog betting fans.

In September 2018, Buffalo went to Minnesota as a 16.5-point underdog with rookie Josh Allen making his first NFL road start. The Josh Allen in his first couple of seasons wasn’t the perennial MVP candidate who takes over games today. “The Josh Allen Experience” was the name some fans used to describe the ups and big-time downs he produced in games, even during the same drives.

That Vikes matchup and the huge spread suggested a difficult afternoon for the rook. Allen was playing a tough defense. Minnesota had finished the previous season first in the NFL in points allowed and would finish 2018 fourth in yards allowed, with Danielle Hunter, Harrison Smith and Anthony Barr all heading to the Pro Bowl.

The dual-threat QB factor that Brunell had above was a big part of this upset too. Allen finished the opening possession with a 10-yard touchdown run. He completed 15 of 22 passes for 196 yards and threw a touchdown and ran for a second. The Bills led 17-0 after one quarter and 27-0 at halftime.

Buffalo kept turning opportunities into points rather than merely trying to preserve a respectable showing.

What takeaway do you get from a September upset win, beyond the talent of the QB?

The huge spread was way too high for a game in the NFL’s first month. There’s not enough data on both sides of the ball to price that big of a spread accurately. The oddsmakers were probably leaning on the Vikings’ 2017 D and discounting the talent of the Bills’ young QB. When you see a spread that big in September, look closely at the underdog.